Calls Needed to Request Veto of Legislation Mandating Land Use Valuation

March 14, 2018

HB 1204 (Hugo) would require that certain property be assessed based on use value rather than fair market value in certain localities meeting specified population growth criteria (Arlington County and Loudoun County).  As passed by the General Assembly, the bill would require that real property of at least 20 acres that is devoted to open space be assessed based on the property’s land use value.

VACo opposes this legislation and has requested that Governor Ralph Northam veto the bill.  Although the bill applies to a limited number of localities now, it sets a worrisome future precedent by requiring a locality to assess property as if it were part of a local program of use value taxation, regardless of whether the locality has adopted use value taxation.  Adopting use value taxation is a local option under current Code.  This bill would supersede that local authority and mandate that certain property be afforded preferential tax treatment.

HB 1204 was prompted by a dispute between two golf courses and Arlington County over the assessments of their properties.  The General Assembly has enacted a process for property owners to appeal assessments.  This bill would interpose the General Assembly in this existing process for resolution of disputes about the valuation of property.

ACTION REQUIRED –Please call or email the Governor’s office and ask for a veto of this legislation.  A link to send an email to Governor Northam is here. The telephone number is 804.786.2211.

KEY POINTS

  • Adopting land use value taxation should be a local decision, not a mandate by the General Assembly. This bill sets a bad precedent by interjecting the state into decisions about local land use and tax policy.
  • A process for appealing assessments is already in place.  Taxpayers may appeal to the local assessor or Commissioner of the Revenue, the local Board of Equalization, and Circuit Court.
  • The bill has some potential unintended consequences for school funding, especially if more property owners in other localities seek similar intervention from the General Assembly in the future. True value of real estate is a major component in the Local Composite Index (LCI).  By declaring that the lower value of the land being assessed as open space in accordance with the bill is the “fair market value,” the affected locality’s true value of real estate would be lower than it would have been had the property been assessed at traditional fair market value (the highest and best use of the property).  Affected localities would then appear to have a lower ability to pay school funding costs, which would lower their LCIs, drawing down additional state dollars.  Since the LCI measures local ability-to-pay on a relative basis, lower LCIs for some localities mean higher LCIs (and fewer state dollars) for others.
  • Similarly, by declaring that the lower value of the land being assessed as open space is “fair market value,” the bill would appear to preclude the collection of “rollback” taxes in the event that affected properties were converted to another use (for example, being sold for development). Ordinarily, property that is part of a program of land use value taxation is subject to five years’ worth of rollback taxes (the difference between the taxes that would have been levied on the fair market value and the taxes collected on the lower assessed value) when the property no longer qualifies for land use assessment.

KEY CONTACTS

Contact Governor Ralph Northam’s Office

VACo Contact: Katie Boyle

 

- Related Blog Posts -

Capitol Contact ALERT – Contact Legislators to Uphold Governor’s Veto of Troubling Assessment Bill

April 16, 2018

View Blog Post

Calls Needed to Oppose Bill Mandating Land Use Value Taxation for Certain Properties

February 5, 2018

View Blog Post

Agritourism ‘home rental’ bill to be heard by subcommittee on Monday

February 10, 2017

View Blog Post